The keyhole passage

“Let us imagine that moved by jealousy, curiosity, or vice I have just glued my ear to the door and looked through a keyhole.”
Jean-Paul Sartre: Being and Nothingness; The Look

 

An impression of Sartre's 'keyhole' passage.

An impression of Sartre’s ‘keyhole’ passage.

About Brad Frederiksen

Engineer and analyst of electro-mechanical and digital systems by day job. Practitioner and student of life and art (broadly construed). View all posts by Brad Frederiksen

4 responses to “The keyhole passage

  • tipota

    i think i get why i’ve heard satre described as nihilist – ah but his musings are so resonant – argh – it’s as if one could only be moved by dark emotion – i would imagine there might be other brighter motivations for looking through a keyhole – one would first need to imagine a keyhole in the first place:) and what one is attracted toward – freud would have something to say about it i imagine:)

    • Brad

      The dark emotions are seemingly essential to Sartre’s philosophy: shame, embarassment, (pride?). As I understand it, which is admittedly based on incomplete reading, those feelings and emotions are a kind of living proof that we have freedom of choice. While I am looking through the keyhole, Sartre writes later,

      “suddenly I hear a footstep. I shudder as a wave of shame sweeps over me. Somebody has seen me. I straighten up. My eyes run over the deserted corridor. It was a false alarm. I breathe a sigh of relief.”

      So the upshot seems to be that, since I feel vulnerable to the look of the Other, I know that person is a potential threat. If they can harm me, or shame me, I know they are free to do so – therefore I am free also. Even if the other person isn’t a real person, or is just a figment of my imagination, it still follows that I am free to make of my existence whatever I will despite the existential nihilist claim that life has no intrinsic meaning or value. Or maybe I am free precisely because there is no intrinsic value or meaning.

      I can imagine being moved by anticipation to look through a keyhole in order to see if the footsteps approaching are those of a dear friend who is due to arrive for our regular get-together.

      I’m not sure what Sartre would say about the freedom of people who no longer feel vulnerable. Probably that it’s improbable:)

      • Brad

        It just struck me that Sartre was probably looking through the keyhole from the outside into a private room. I was imagining looking through from the wrong side!

      • tipota

        looking from the inside out seems quite different than from the outside in, in terms of perception/experience/motivation etc. – from the outside looking in is much more existentially
        neurotic haha really out there

Follow Instructions on Top Card

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: